allowing TM to be used to describe a different entity could be literally false lawyer advertising

Rosenbaum & Associates, P.C. v. Morgan & Morgan,
2018 WL 1768050, No. 17-4250 (E.D. Pa. Apr. 12, 2018)
Rosenbaum sued various Morgan defendants for false advertising
of personal injury lawyering services in Philadelphia.  Defendants started advertising Morgan &
Morgan’s personal injury services in the Philadelphia market in December 2015, though
no attorneys worked on personal injury matters for a Morgan & Morgan entity
in a Philadelphia office. “At some point, an entity called Morgan & Morgan
Philadelphia opened an office in Philadelphia but Morgan & Morgan PA denies
it has an office in Philadelphia.”  In
January 2017, Morgan & Morgan PA hired a relatively inexperienced Pennsylvania
attorney as the only attorney in its Philadelphia office, but this allegedly
merely occurred “to perpetuate the charade [all Morgan & Morgan entities]
are handling personal injury claims for clients in the Philadelphia market.”
The disclaimer “it is not a referral
service” was allegedly false or misleading because the Morgan & Morgan
entities, in reality, refer all or nearly all of cases from Philadelphia
clients to other law firms.  Billboard
claims stating that “Morgan & Morgan” has “Offices Philadelphia” were
allegedly false because Morgan & Morgan PA denies having an office in
Philadelphia and instead states the separate entity Morgan & Morgan
Philadelphia owns the Philadelphia office. Similarly, internet advertising that
“ ‘[Morgan & Morgan’s] attorneys in our Philadelphia office handle cases in
the following practice areas,’ referring to various types [of] personal injury
claims, and identifying [Morgan & Morgan] as ‘Personal Injury Lawyers in
Philadelphia’ ” were allegedly false for the same reasons.
The Morgan & Morgan entities and attorneys allegedly
never intend to represent personal injury clients in the Philadelphia area but
refers “all or substantially all” potential clients who contact Morgan &
Morgan to another law firm for a referral fee.  The statements “I’m your lawyer,” “We’re all here for you,” and
“You don’t pay us unless we’re successful” were sufficiently alleged to
be literally false because Morgan & Morgan PA attorneys never represent,
never are there for, or never are successful for Philadelphia based clients.
After discovery, Rosenbaum alleged additional statements are
false or misleading and also sues other Morgan & Morgan entities and
individuals.  The court refused “to
examine each statement in a vacuum and strike Rosenbaum’s allegations about
certain statements because those statements are not misleading in isolation…. The
full factual record of summary judgement is the time to examine each
advertisement in context and determine whether they are false or misleading
instead of examining the statements in isolation based solely on allegations.”
Morgan & Morgan PA moved to dismiss as to new
claims, arguing that billboards advertising “Morgan & Morgan Offices
Philadelphia” weren’t literally false because “Morgan & Morgan” isn’t
“Morgan & Morgan PA.”  The court
disagreed; Rosenbaum alleged that the billboards in the Philadelphia area were
literally false when they used the trade name “Morgan & Morgan” through the
trademark owned by Morgan & Morgan Global to advertise an office in
Philadelphia when Morgan & Morgan Global and Morgan & Morgan PA deny
having an office in Philadelphia.
As for which defendants were responsible, Morgan &
Morgan Global allegedly permitted its trademark “Morgan & Morgan” to be
used in billboard ads stating Morgan & Morgan has an office in Philadelphia
when allegedly neither Morgan & Morgan Global nor Morgan & Morgan PA had
an office in Philadelphia. Allowing the trademark to be used in an ad with a
literally false statement was sufficient to state a claim.

from Blogger

This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s