“unique” and “innovative” are puffery

LoggerHead Tools, LLC v. Sears Holdings Corp., 2016 WL
5080028, No. 12-cv-9033 (N.D. Ill. Sept. 20, 2016)
LoggerHead sued Sears under the Lanham Act and Illinois
state law for false advertising; the court granted summary judgment to
Sears.  LoggerHead sells a hand tool, the
Bionic Wrench, which Sears sold from 2009. 
In 2012, Sears sought a Bionic Wrench replacement to be sold under the
Sears Craftsman brand and sent LoggerHead’s patent to a patent lawyer, who
identified another patented tool that could be used as a model for a
replacement wrench and that (he opined) would not infringe.  In late 2012, Sears began retailing the Max
Axess Locking Wrench (MALW).
In DTC ads for the MALW, Sears stated: “[i]f you want
maximum versatility in a single wrench, then you’ll love the latest innovation
from Craftsman, the Max Axess Locking Wrench.” The product packaging for the
MALW shows a picture of the wrench, the term “Unique Design,” and, underneath
that, the phrase “Adapts to a wide range of fastener sizes and grips fasteners
on all sides to prevent rounding.” The packaging also contains a dotted line
going from the writing to the picture of the wrench.  Sears issued a press release with similar

Craftsman package
LoggerHead argued that, taken in context, these features
were literally false: (1) the “Unique Design” statement, (2) “Adapts to a wide
range of fastener sizes and grips fasteners on all sides to prevent rounding”
statement, (3) the illustration of the MALW and (4) the white line connecting
them.  First, because the MALW copied its
design from the Bionic Wrench, it wasn’t unique. Second, the “unique” claim was
connected to the claim, “Adapts to a wide range of fastener sizes and grips
fasteners on all sides to prevent rounding,” also false as a uniqueness claim,
as was the connection between the “unique” claim and the image of the MALW’s
tool head.
The court found no literal falsity in the uniqueness claim “given
that there are admitted differences between the MALW and the Bionic Wrench.”  Plus, “unique” has previously been deemed
puffery.  Although “unique design” might
not be literally false, it could be misleading, but LoggerHead didn’t provide
any consumer perception evidence.
What about “latest innovation from Craftsman” in the ads?  Sears argued that this couldn’t be false
advertising because of Dastar, but the
Supreme Court did not “hold that a false claim of origin is the only way to
violate [the Lanham Act].” Gensler v. Strabala, 764 F.3d 735, 736 (7th Cir.
2014). Still, this statement wasn’t literally false, since it didn’t say what
the innovation was, and courts have also found “innovative” to be puffery.
As for the press release, LoggerHead argued that it falsely stated:
“Despite some visual similarities to other tools on the market, Craftsman Max
Axess Locking Wrench operates in a different way, using a mechanism design[ed]
in the 1950s.” LoggerHead claimed literal falsity because the MALW uses a mechanism
designed by LoggerHead, and also alleged that the press release falsely implied
that the MALW is made in America, when it is made in China.
Sears argued that the press release wasn’t commercial
advertising or promotion.  The court
thought that the press release had characteristics of commercial speech
(product references, economic motivation for the speech) despite not being in a
traditional ad format, but there was no evidence that the press release was sufficiently
disseminated to the relevant purchasing public, even though it was posted on
Sears’ website.

As for falsity, the press release didn’t say that the MALW
was made in America and LoggerHead didn’t explain why the release was
misleading on that point. The phrase “operates in a different way” was
subjective and not literally false, since the MALW concededly contains some
features that the Bionic Wrench does not, such as a locking mechanism. 

from Blogger http://ift.tt/2dculao

This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s