Reading list: The Kids Don’t Stand a Chance: Unfair and Deceptive Advertising in Children’s Apps

 Mary Kate Fernandez,  The Kids Don’t Stand a Chance: Unfair and Deceptive Advertising in Children’s Apps, 66 Loy. L. Rev. 211 (2020)


The University of Michigan released a startling study (“the
Michigan Study”) in October 2018 which unveiled that “manipulative and
disruptive” advertisements are deceptively built into phone applications (“apps”)
designed for children.
 The results of this study led
members of the United States Senate and several public interest groups to
petition the Federal Trade Commission (“FTC”) to investigate apps marketed
specifically to children.
 The current federal administrative
regime for regulating deceptive advertising targeted at children, however,
falls far short of what is necessary to enable the FTC or any other federal
agency to respond to the revelations in the Michigan Study with meaningful
protections for children.

A striking passage on host selling:

This advertising practice, illegal during children’s television
programming, is fundamentally unfair to child consumers. Yet, multiple apps
designed for children heavily employ host-selling.

 For example, in PAW
Patrol: Air and Sea Adventures
, the commercial characters are not only the
object of gameplay but also have interactions with the user.
 Characters make faces
indicating feelings of disappointment when the user does not click on locked
items that require payment.
 App characters also
show disapproval when the player is unable to accomplish a certain mission
because he did not make a required purchase.
 The Michigan Study
stated that such tactics “could be characterized as social pressure or validation”
and “may also lead children to feel an emotionally charged need to make
 In Doctor Kids,
the main character bursts into tears if the player does not make an inapp  purchase.
 In Barbie Magical
, Barbie narrates and specifically encourages users to use “locked”
items that require making a purchase.

Most problematic of the
host-selling examples was Strawberry Shortcake Puppy Palace. In this
app, Strawberry Shortcake instructs users to choose a puppy to play with, but
only one out of eight puppies can be played with for free. 
Every other puppy is
 If the child selects a
locked puppy, Strawberry Shortcake says, “Oops. To play with [name of puppy],
you’ll need to get the puppy pack. Or you can unlock everything and get the
best deal.”
 Throughout the game,
Strawberry Shortcake has thought bubbles. Some tell the user that the puppy is
sad, and the user should give the puppy what it wants. But oftentimes the item
that the puppy “wants” is locked, and when the child selects it, Strawberry
Shortcake tells the child to buy “the activities pack to keep the puppy happy.”

from Blogger

This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s